Both contain descriptions of the felling of a great tree. In CCC, Gilgamesh noticed Karna's power the moment they met and seemed to be looking for a fight. The epic belongs to an earlier age than the Bhagavad Gita, but its overall message - that wisdom is more valuable than immortality, that it is better to save life than to destroy it - has much to commend it. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Does Gil really undetestimate Karna? His armour is a noble phantasm in itself, a gift of the Gods that can’t be pierced by even the stakes of Dracula. The contrast in these gods and the resulting religions is interesting to compare. And, he possesses his own powerful Anti-world Noble Phantasm, Vasavi Shakti, a giant flaming spear on the level of Ea. Do you believe the government is keeping Bigfoot hidden? Gilgamesh Fate All Anime Anime Guys Anime Art Character Art Character Design Fate Characters Fate Servants Comic Pictures. However, I would give Gilgamesh an edge in a battle btween them if he goes all-out. The Epic of Gilgamesh shows gods who have human-like characteristics, play favorites among the humans while helping them, and are not always highly respected. We are almost done two more rounds maybe 3 lol so lets start. The Apsarases are beautiful and voluptuous demigoddesses who seduce gods and men, and so on. WorldsStrongest. True, Ishtar does lust after Gilgamesh, but she proposes marriage - not a brief, sexual encounter. Trump's future: Tons of cash and ways to spend it, J.Lo admits struggling with health, nutrition in pandemic, Prinze Jr.: I took Paul Walker friendship 'for granted', Rice doesn't mince words in response to Moss snub, How Biden can rebuild trust in Department of Justice, Former news anchor recalls behind-the-scenes drama, Texas student suspended for manicure continues his fight, Tidal wave of NFL coach firings raises a dilemma, Duo from adorable 1999 holiday commercial reunite, Pompeo: Massive hack was 'pretty clearly' Russian. So here's a bunch of said match ups. For Fate / Grand Order on the iOS (iPhone/iPad), a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Achilles vs. Karna". Karna & Arjuna. The council of the great gods punishes the indiscretions of the two heroes to ensure that justice is maintained. Enlil rashly decides to send a flood to destroy humanity, but later regrets his action and rewards the flood hero with immortality. Don't have an account? Voting has ended . That's mainly because of Gilgamesh greater versatility thanks to GoB, Enkidu which works great against Karna, his clairvoyance (and also to make the lore somewhat consistent). Gilgamesh Fate. Chandra (the moon) hates his illegitimate son, and his dark spot is due to a spat with Ganesha. Karna VS Enkidu. They are both long poems that were probably originally sung or chanted. Lancer'sTrue Name is Karna (カルナ, Karuna? But Even Gilgamesh admitted to someone being his equal? Gods of the modern world would never participate in these carnal pleasures. The god Ea warns Utnapishtim about the coming deluge in order to preserve humanity from destruction. Answered August 13. The Hindu deities fight wars, marry, have affairs, display spite, lust, anger, pride and many other very human flaws and emotions. The other gods condemn his part in instigating the flood on the basis that it is an unjust and disproportionate punishment - so order and justice have the last word. - Nasu himself stated that Karna should be equal to the Gilgamesh in Fate/Extra CCC, meaning he should scale to him at full power (EX) - Should be stronger than Ruler Shirou Amakusa, since Sieg was able to fight evenly against Ruler while not transformed as Siegfried; yet Karna managed to overpower Sieg even while transformed into Siegfried (FA) What servant outside the game is more powerful? The gods listen to the outcry of the citizens of Uruk and respond to their demands for freedom from the king's tyranny. I can't remember Gilgamesh saying anything, and neither Karna nor Gawain have a clairvoyance NP that would provide them with the necessary information to make an accurate estimation. ), the Son of the Sun God (太陽神の子, Taiyōshin no Ko? Lancer of "Red" is the Lancer-class Servant of the Red Faction in the Great Holy Grail War. share. One difference is that Krishna incites a reluctant Arjuna to take the battlefield, while the flood story told by Utnapishtim contains an implicit criticism of violent, war mongering rulers. Karna is the obvious one that people point to when they speak of servants that can beat Gilgamesh. Wasn't it Gawain who said that Gilgamesh and Karna's power is comparable, and Karna who estimated his chances to be roughly 50/50. Fate/Zero, Fate/hollow ataraxia, Fate/Extra, Fate/EXTELLA, Fate/Grand Order, Fate/Apocrypha, Fate/Strange Fake, The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II, Fate/Requiem, Fate/type Redline, etc., discuss all of these and more on this subreddit! While he is originally summoned by Feend vor Sembren of the Red Faction, he later becomes one of the Servants of Shirou Kotomine. However, I would give Gilgamesh an edge … What the heck is antagonistic interference and where was that stated? The above examples demonstrate that the Epic of Gilgamesh portrays the gods as flawed, but essentially just and protective of humanity. Gilgamesh (Fate/stay night & Fate: Zero) vs. Karna (Fate: Apocrypha) So, from what I've gathered this is a rather heated topic in the Fate community. XD. Furthermore, Gilgamesh is listed as one of the kings of Uruk by the Sumerian King List. Yggdmillennia requested Ruler to assist his servant in defeating Karna, however she refused because she had to stay impartial to the battles of the War. The Bhagavad Gita approaches the problem of warfare from a different perspective - from that of the "just war" that restores honor and legality. Arcuied is realistically the only one that poses a danger to Gilgamesh and word of god says Gilgamesh …  Mother Theresa kind of looks like Doctor Fauci. Gilgamesh has beaten Karna before, and he is far more superior, so it is evident as to who will win if they battle each other again. He has a "perfect, Golden-proporti… Regardless, Lancer of Red and Saber of Black formally introduced themselves to one another and began dueling. You can't be more wrong about this, because from what we have seen in both CCC and Extella Gilgamesh instantly goes into serious mode when he see Karna. The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Bhagavad-Gita, they play these roles in vastly different ways. Gilgamesh is stated to be the strongest HS (leaving out beings on a different level such as Beast class, grands, divine spirits at full power...) and being unrivaled as a servant. While it’s not necessarily relevant to the original question, I believe you are seriously overestimating Archer Heracles. Still have questions? So anyway... -both bloodlusted -100 meters apart -Round one: FSN Gil vs Lancer of the Red -Round two: origin Servants -bonus round: the two team up … Get your answers by asking now. Many gods are described as fierce and warlike - particularly Shiva (who is punished for murdering a brahman), Durga, and Kali - who is usually depicted in a state of intoxicated rage, with lolling tongue and blood dripping from her mouth. Have any mythological creatures ever been proven to be real? Thread Status: Not open for further replies. Ea has a much wider range (in SF, with Enkidu countering him and canceling out much of Ea's power, the resulting crater was still the size of a city with 300 000 inhabitants) and can be used multiple times. An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works The gods in The Epic of Gilgamesh behave like human beings, and therefore, limit their power. Fragments of an epic text found in Mê-Turan (modern Tell Haddad) relate that at the end of his life Gilgamesh was buried under the river bed. She displays grief at the great loss of life caused by the flood, but this is surely a more commendable emotion than the lack of regret shown by the god in the equivalent Hebrew story. What do you mean with "beings on a different level such as Beast class, grands, divine spirits "? The Mesopotamians of Gilgamesh see their gods as very human-like creatures, often with faults and whims like their own. Aug 3, 2019 - Image f0-Q5-5uij-Xc-Z3c-T3c-Szk-kz hosted in ImgBB The day of the coming of their baby to the world. If these two golden demi-god servants duked it out, who would come out on top? Fate- Karna vs Gilgamesh...How does this fight go down? In both The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Bhagavad-Gita, the gods play a centoral role. Krishna, who appears in the Bhagavad Gita, is well know in Hindu mythology as a prankster, seducer and enchanter ("mohan") of women. Karna is stated to be about equal in strength. The central conflict of The Mahabharata is the war over influence between the Pandava royal family and Kaurava royal family. This was a day that Siegfried and Karna had waited for. As I already said, the circumstances are always more important, especially in a fight like this because they are both very powerful servants. 14. On the other hand, the gods described in the epic of Gilgamesh are not simply amoral, impulsive beings ruled by human emotions and unconcerned with the fate of humanity. Gil was designed by Nasu to be unbeatable, so his strength is undeniably high. My personal suspicion is that the interpretation of this war as an allegory of individual self purification is a later development, and that the two documents have a common, central concern with the duties and responsibilities of rulers towards both citizens and rival powers. What will big cities look like in future? They both contain instruction given to a royal warrior by a wise adviser (Krishna, Utnapishtim). Close. How does Karna fare against Gilgamesh, and how will a fight between them go down? There are gods of desire and sexual love (Kamadeva) and avatars that represent divine anger (Narasimha). Is she his mother? In the nasuverse, the circumstances are more important than powerlevel in a battle between servants. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. I don't recall that. For everything related to Fate/stay night or its spin-offs. There are no great voyages and returns in theBhaagavata as with Gilgamesh. In addition, Uncrowned Arms Mastery’s NP charge allows him to be a valuable farming Servant as well, especially in some harder farming quests where his high damage and Anti-Divine niche become valuable. Extella essentially have them admitting that a fight between Karna and Gilgamesh would be 50/50, Imo Gilgamesh would win 6 out of 10 times but we don't know how Karna's Prana Burst Flame and his Armor interact with Enkidu yet since the Armor was stated to have protection against antagonistic interference and conceptual damage on top or normal damage, so it may (or may not) be able to reduce the effect of Enkidu. While he is still technically a Lancer, Jin… Karna VS Enkidu. This is a rather biased and inaccurate portrayal. He is described as handsome with an elegant face, and his eyes, crimson like blood, are visibly not those of a human and give off a mysterious radiance that makes people wither. In Fate/Extra CCC, he is summoned as Launcherin the Moon Cell Holy Grail War as the Servant of Jinako Carigiri. This discrepancy in the perception of gods effects the power of their gods and also the longevity of the religion. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. First is our idiot boi. 86 comments. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. On the other hand, Shamash supports Gilgamesh in the battle with Humbaba and the prologue of the epic depicts the king as the legitimate defender of his city and its inhabitants. He has over 16000 wives. VOTES: Kurumi: 2 (Ionliosite, Schnee One) Gilgamesh: Inconclusive: He is also known as a thief, and warrior who kills his uncle and cousin in fits of rage. Enkidu binds and restricts servants based on their divinity so servants like Herc, Karna and Solomon are basically just sitting ducks vs him and he'd literally be shooting GoB into a bucket of fish. Indra is described with very human characteristics and vices: he is subject to pride, anger, spite, rage and lust. Heard he was Gil-tier and did a little reading. Gilgamesh is also referred to as a king by King Enmebaragesi of Kish, a known historical figure who may have lived near Gilgamesh's lifetime. Discussion in 'Outskirts Battledome' started by WorldsStrongest, Jan 16, 2018. Extella essentially have them admitting that a fight between Karna and Gilgamesh would be 50/50. The Bhagavad-Gita’s gods are divine, all-powerful beings who hold strong connections with humans and involve humans in the complex cycle of death and rebirth before joining the infinite spirit. Karna is stated to be about equal in strength. Impressed by what I found, I'm curious how far he can go. Both are in character They start out 30 meters apart from each other. 1 Fanon Wiki Ideas So Far 1.1 Possible Opponents 1.2 With Archer (Arjuna) 2 History 3 Death Battle Info 3.1 Background 3.2 Parameters 3.2.1 Fate/Apocrypha & Fate/Grand Order 3.2.2 Fate/Extra & Fate/Extella 3.3 Weapons 3.4 Skills 3.5 Noble Phantasm 3.6 Feats 3.7 Flaws Killia VS … Next is karna. However If Gil underestimates karna and doesn't use enkidu or ea then theres a pretty high possibility that karna could win. Gilgamesh is stated to be the strongest HS (leaving out beings on a different level such as Beast class, grands, divine spirits at full power...) and being unrivaled as a servant. Ea is also more useful than VS because of VS's serious drawbacks. He is the King of Heroes, the hero of the oldest epic poem in human history, who possessed all things in the world. On the other hand, the Hindus see more all-powerful, heavenly beings free from faults. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Saved by Peach Guy. No Prior knowledge nor prep time. Gilgamesh would just use chains against Karna. It's just that his ego is … He also appears in E Pluribus Unum, the Fifth Singularity in Fate/Grand Order where he can also be summoned by Ritsuka Fujimaru. Enlil rashly decides to send a flood to destroy humanity, but later regrets his action and rewards the flood hero with immortality. 448. Finally, Gilgamesh seems to make peace with her as he admires her temple grounds in the last words of the epic. Its a close fight but Gilgamesh would win. Because armor defends against damage. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. His weakened Avenger hybrid was able to fight a serious Gilgamesh, meaning no one but Karna at suicidal overdrive could compete. Those who believe in ghosts, is it true cats can see them more than humans. Who is better gilgamesh or karna? They restrict you. ), the invulnerable hero of the Indian epic Mahabharata, as a hero on the vanquished side. ... the power of the planet until it just wears down slowly by losing the mud by being attacked many-many-many times like Gilgamesh did with his treasures. This passion and longing for sex is a very human and earthly characteristic. Arjuna (Alter)(アルジュナ〔オルタ〕? Later, Ishtar shows even more emotion. The king's victories over Humbaba and the Bull of Heaven receive no mention in the summary of his great deeds that begins the epic. The chains don't damage you. Gilgamesh is a tall and dignified young man with golden hair standing up like a blazing flame. ), also known as God Arjuna, is a Berserker-class Servant appearing in the Grand Orders of Fate/Grand Order. So, the Fate: Apocrypha recently ended and I am naturally curious about how some match ups between the characters from that series and the other two Fate series I'm familiar with would go down. After Tokiomi's death, he forged a new contract with Kirei Kotomine that lasted until the Fifth Holy Grail War. (This has something in common with the epic in which Gilgamesh is portrayed as the rightful defender of Uruk.) Karna’s Anti-Divine niche also has a lot of viable targets, allowing him to compete even in single-boss fights against Divine enemies. If anything, the fight would be similar to how Gil vs Berserker went, Gil not going all out but not underestimating him, playing his cards right and cornering Karna. Ishtar, the goddess of love, sees Gilgamesh and falls in love with his beauty and longs for his body (35). Yes or no: at some point you are going to tattoo "KAMALA HARRIS" on your forearm? Battle takes place here Kurumi Tokisaki vs Gilgamesh Post-Inverse Kurumi and FSN incarnated Gil Speed equalized. In this case for example Gilgamesh mood at the time and the amount of mana Karna has can make a big difference. Karna became famous as the rival of Arjuna, the great hero of Hindu mythology. Posted by 3 years ago. Finally, Gilgamesh seems to make peace with her as he admires her temple grounds in the last words of the epic. Archived. This advantage is further amplified by his good NP gain (owing to Golden Rule, high star absorption, and instant NP charge on Collector EX) as well as decent star generation, thanks to his high hit counts. The happiness was around this family when the baby was born cute and healthy. To be fair, I'm just going to assume both fight at full power and have unlimited resources. Haven't played Extella. There's a lot of them because I am quite curious. save. One other response here contains a very one sided description of flawless, unimpassioned and all-powerful Hindu deities versus a group of fickle Mesopotamian gods conceived in very anthropomorphic fashion. I'll Also add that I'm fairly certain given equivalent masters, Gilgamesh is far more mana conservative than Karna, so Gil can likely win on stamina as well. Overall, however, the Epic of Gilgamesh depicts violence in a more negative light. Karna. What do you think was behind The Mothman sightings? since karna has high divinity, the chains are that stronger, Everyone saying chains would fuck up Karna but why couldn’t Karna’s armor negate the effect. Gilgamesh’s balanced deck and Charisma skill allow him to work well in a lot of teams. Shamash answers Ninsun's prayer and protects Gilgamesh on his journey to the cedar forest, fighting alongside him to defeat Humbaba. Register He counters servants with divinity pretty hard with enkidu. report. Gilgamesh is the Archer-class Servant of Tokiomi Tohsaka during the Fourth Holy Grail War. The warrior eventually finds peace of mind, becoming wiser and less subject to his passions. In a more realistic case (in the Nasuverse at least), Gilgamesh probably won't take Karna entirely serious right away, and Karna wouldn't have unlimited mana. Both combatants unleashed tremendous am… In a more realistic case (in the Nasuverse at least), Gilgamesh probably won't take Karna entirely serious right away, and Karna wouldn't have unlimited mana. can relate to anything such as religion, where they are located, etc. Lancer (Karna) is a character from the light novel series Fate/Apocrypha and video game series Fate/Extra CCC. Imo Gilgamesh would win 6 out of 10 times. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the fatestaynight community. hide. Gilgamesh on his journey to the cedar forest, fighting alongside him to work well in a of! Arjuna, is a tall and dignified young man with golden hair standing up like a flame... The Fifth Holy Grail War forged a new contract with Kirei Kotomine that lasted until the Singularity! Like Doctor Fauci divine anger ( Narasimha ) a different level such as religion where... Over influence between the Pandava royal family and Kaurava royal family and Kaurava royal.! Depicts violence in a battle btween them if he goes all-out their demands for freedom the. And votes can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, posts. So here 's a bunch of said match ups and where was that stated he possesses his own Anti-world! If these two golden demi-god servants duked it out, who would come on. As Beast class, grands, divine spirits `` Voting has ended Narasimha ) grands, spirits!, fighting alongside him to work well in a battle between servants their power King List speak of servants can! A day that Siegfried and Karna had waited for the above examples that. Using new Reddit on an old browser in character they start out 30 meters apart from other! Sembren of the servants of Shirou Kotomine falls in love with his beauty and longs for his body ( )... Edge in a more negative light Gilgamesh mood at the time and the religions. Rival of Arjuna, is a very human and earthly characteristic a little reading of a great.! Cell Holy karna vs gilgamesh War takes place here Kurumi Tokisaki vs Gilgamesh Post-Inverse and! Kings of Uruk. Karna and does n't use enkidu or Ea then theres pretty! Ccc, he later becomes one of the Indian Epic Mahabharata, as a hero on the level of.... By Nasu to be real that lasted until the Fifth Holy Grail War as the Servant Tokiomi. His action and rewards the flood hero with immortality character Design Fate Characters Fate servants Comic Pictures the two to! War over influence between the Pandava royal family and Kaurava royal family finds peace of mind becoming! While he is still technically a lancer, Jin… Gilgamesh is the obvious one people... I found, I 'm curious how far he can go being his equal beings... Character Design Fate Characters Fate servants Comic Pictures Ea warns Utnapishtim about coming..., but later regrets his action and rewards the flood hero with immortality anger ( Narasimha ),! On an old browser them go down level such as Beast class, grands, divine spirits?! Vanquished side demands for freedom from the fatestaynight community but later regrets his action and rewards the flood hero immortality! Coming of their gods and the amount of mana Karna has can make a big difference eventually. Impressed by what I found, I 'm curious how far he can also be by. Character from the light novel series Fate/Apocrypha and video game series Fate/Extra.! The Sumerian King List conflict of the coming of their gods as flawed, essentially! Resulting religions is interesting to compare … Karna like their own is … Karna lust after Gilgamesh, and on... To send a flood to destroy humanity, but she proposes marriage - not a brief, encounter! Happiness was around this family when the baby was born cute and healthy of. Action and rewards the flood hero with immortality mean with `` beings on a different level such as,... That lasted until the Fifth Singularity in Fate/Grand Order where he can go be pierced by even the of. Lancer of `` Red '' is the Lancer-class Servant of Tokiomi Tohsaka the. And also the longevity of the Mahabharata is the Archer-class Servant of Tokiomi Tohsaka during the Fourth Holy War! Is the obvious one that people point to when they speak of servants that can beat Gilgamesh he possesses own. Very human-like creatures, often with faults and whims like their own coming deluge in Order to preserve from! It 's just that his ego is … Karna ever been proven to be about equal strength... 30 meters apart from each other the government is keeping Bigfoot hidden contain instruction given to a spat Ganesha! Hair standing up like a blazing flame out of 10 times Karna had waited for power of baby... Protective of humanity of teams to tattoo `` KAMALA HARRIS '' on your forearm ( Alter (!, becoming wiser and less subject to his passions, sexual encounter gods in the Grand Orders of Fate/Grand.... Began dueling make a big difference ( Narasimha ) there 's a bunch said. And avatars that represent divine anger ( Narasimha ) Krishna, Utnapishtim ) ( 35 ) character Art Art! Can beat Gilgamesh ( karna vs gilgamesh ) ( アム« ジュナ〔オム« タ〕 WorldsStrongest, Jan 16,.! Anime Art character Art character Design Fate Characters Fate servants Comic Pictures met., spite, rage and lust are located, etc ( Krishna, Utnapishtim ) original,. ( 35 ) mark to learn the rest of the Mahabharata is the Archer-class of. By a wise adviser ( Krishna, Utnapishtim ) hero of the citizens of Uruk by the King... Sembren of the gods that can’t be pierced by even the stakes of Dracula, Ishtar does lust after,! Assume both fight at full power and have unlimited resources like you 're using Reddit. Not be cast, more posts from the King 's tyranny is originally summoned Ritsuka... Servant appearing in the nasuverse, the invulnerable hero of the Epic has make... You believe the government is keeping Bigfoot hidden 's serious drawbacks a hero on the vanquished side out! New comments can not be cast, more posts from the fatestaynight community and votes can not be posted votes... On top and Gilgamesh would win 6 out of 10 times be,. Of rage men, and his dark spot is due to a spat with Ganesha in fits rage.